Call us today! 210-876-4086 info@mjkda.com
MJKDA Customer Experience Consulting
☰

Leadership and Change

Why Your Customer Satisfaction Score Is Flat: Start With Where You Rank

A green heartbeat line on a black screen, mostly flat.

A flat customer satisfaction score is hard to interpret until you know where you rank among your peers. Start there, then drill down into the areas where customers say you are missing the mark, and audit your recent initiatives against those insights.

Beyond these three checks, four main obstacles tend to stall customer experience (CX): window dressing, basics that slip, impractical quick-fixes, and budget cuts. This guide is for executives and data owners whose companies are ranked against their peers in a public study, such as a J.D. Power study for your industry. In this context, a "flat score" means your performance has stagnated across recent survey cycles.

Start with your rank among peers, not the score on its own

A public study ranks companies against each other, so much of what it tells you is in the rank order. Ask first whether you are near the top or the bottom among your peers, and write the answer down before you look at anything else.

Know who your peers are, too. In a utility study, you are measured against the other utilities in your region and your industry. Regionally you have to keep up: if a peer introduces an app that customers can use, you cannot ignore it. The study is the customer's outside-in view of you, showing where customers see you doing well and where they see you failing.

Then find the areas where customers say you are missing

After rank comes the drill down. Look for the specific areas where customers rate you lowest, because that is where you may be missing. Rank tells you where you stand, and the drill down tells you where to look.

Drilling down means reading each low area as something a customer actually lived through. In a utility that can be how an outage was handled and how openly it was explained, or a bill that was accurate the first time. It can also be a phone line staffed for the people who still call, or how a field crew looked and behaved at the house.

What customers weigh depends on your industry. In a utility, the two biggest drivers are whether the service works, which means whether it is reliable, and price. A poor storm response can also pull a utility's score down, and the model behind a study is reset from year to year, so what matters most shifts a little.

J.D. Power's residential electric utility study shows the shape of what customers weigh. It covers residential customers of large and midsize electric utilities across four U.S. regions. It rates eight areas: monthly cost, trust, safety and reliability, ease of doing business, information provided, people, problem resolution and digital channels.

Memory matters as well. If a utility has had a very bad storm response or a major rate case, that bad press can linger for three or four years, because people remember how badly they were treated. Because of that memory, it is important to keep scores consistent and improving, and a flat score is worth reading against the last few years.

Water, gas, electric and internet companies are each rated on what matters to their own customers, and the same is true across industries. Read your own study in your own industry's terms, and do not assume the two utility drivers apply to an automotive dealer, an airline, or an insurer. If you track NPS, the net promoter score, treat it as a direction: it shows which way customers lean, and it does not get down to what is going well or what to fix.

A low rating can also run the other way. An area can be rated low even when the work behind it is good, because customers have not been told about it. A company can do something well and not toot its own horn. Where customers do not recognize you as doing well, you probably also have something to change internally. So, when a low rating meets work you believe is good, check both halves: ask whether customers know about it, and ask whether something inside needs to change.

Check what you worked on against those areas

A company that comes to us for customer experience consulting usually has a score, or its own view of what customers are saying. It has not been able to work out exactly what to do to improve. If that is you, put two lists side by side: the areas where customers rate you lowest, and everything your company worked on over the last year.

When a company that calls us believes it has done everything, the effort is usually not unified. What helps is to get focused on the critical few things and stop working on what is non-productive. How to pick the critical few is covered in an earlier article. Here the only question is whether your list reaches the weak areas.

The dealer group below is constructed. It is not a client, and the table shows directions only, with no measured figures. Picture the service department of a mid-size regional dealer group, ranked against its peers in a public study, with a score that has not changed across the last two study results. Read it in this order.

Reading a flat score in order

StepWhat to askWhat the dealer group finds
1. RankWhere do we rank?The lower half of its regional peers, the same place as in the last study. A nearby peer has introduced an online appointment tool, and this group has not.
2. Drill downWhere do customers say we are missing?The two lowest-rated areas are getting an appointment and hearing how the repair is going.
3. The year's workWhat did last year's work touch?A showroom refresh, a loyalty email series and a new customer app. None changes how an appointment is booked or how a customer hears about a repair.
4. The four thingsWhich of the four things below is in play?Confirming the appointment and calling with a repair update are skipped on busy days. The old scheduling system cannot send updates, so the workaround is a text from the service advisor.
5. First moveWhat do we do first?Put the appointment and repair-update basics ahead of everything else on the list.

Read in this order, the same flat score becomes a short list of things to change.

For a dealer, the stake is return visits. A dealer wants the customer happy with the product and with the service, so that the customer comes back for service and replaces the vehicle there. A service score that has not moved is a fair prompt to ask whether the group is winning those visits.

If you would like to read your last two study results with both partners, put them beside your list of last year's work and bring both.

Four things that hold customer experience back: window dressing, slipping basics, practical limits and budget cuts

Row four of the table points here. Check your own year against each one.

  • Window dressing. Companies do the feel-good things and the easy things, and those are not necessarily what makes the biggest difference in the long run. On your two lists, window dressing shows up as work that is easy to do and easy to see, with no line to a low-rated area. Separate what makes a difference from what is nice to have, and shore up the need-to-have items first.
  • Slipping basics. Companies get starry eyed about new technology or new processes and drift away from the basics. Automotive is a big one. People know what to do and do not do it, because daily activities and box-checking forms pull their attention away. The remedy is "sticking to the basics": repeating them in a consistently good way, over and over, because the small daily things aimed at customers are the ones that get missed.
  • Practical limits. Prioritizing means knowing the biggest movers in customer experience and what is practical for your organization to move. Some things matter a great deal to customers and are not practical to improve in the short term, for political, environmental or investment reasons such as old systems and no money to replace them. In that case look for "band aids and workarounds" in how you communicate and interact, on the web and on mobile for example, instead of spending millions on a system.
  • Budget cuts. When budgets are cut and the economy turns down, training and customer experience tend to be among the first things to go, because they sit outside what a company counts as core operations. My partner John Farstvedt says this does a lot of damage.

Each of the four leaves a trace on your two lists. John adds a related pattern: companies put marketing money and energy into winning new customers while the customers they already have are disregarded or even mistreated. Winning a new customer costs much more than keeping one. If last year's list is mostly outreach to new people, that is worth noting next to the window dressing.

Basics slip because everyone knows them. John's picture is the person who has filled out the same form a thousand times and decides to skip it this time, sure that nothing will be missed. The work turns tactical and task oriented, and attention moves away from what matters to a customer. The dealer group's skipped appointment confirmations and repair-update calls on busy days show the other half of it: daily activity crowding out the small steps that matter to a customer.

A practical limit does not end the work. John's loop of continuous improvement still applies: gather what customers say, find the root cause, tell customers you received it, and make the correction. Then tell the people who deal with customers, and update the website and other resources customers use. Our article on why leadership's decisions never reach the front line covers how to get that message to them.

Where the cause is an old system, John points to the web and mobile as places to communicate around it, as with the dealer group's text from the service advisor.

On budget cuts, John's view is that many companies treat customer experience as nice to have, not integral, so it waits until times get good again. If last year was a tight one, check whether training or customer experience was cut, and whether the cut touches a weak area.

Fix what customers already told you before you add anything new

Before you add anything new, read what customers already tell you. The reasons they call and complain are a list of things to fix, so they never have to call you about them again. Feedback that gets no action costs you twice: the people who gave it stop giving it, and you lose what it could have shown you.

What to write down before your next review

Put three things on one page. At the top, write where you rank among your peers. Under it, list the three areas where customers rate you lowest, taken from the study's own breakdown of rated areas. Beside it, list what the company worked on last year. Then cross out every item on that list that touches none of those areas. The crossed-out items are your first suspects for window dressing. What is left reached the areas customers rate lowest, and the next question for it is whether the basics held.

Short answer: a flat score is first a question of rank, then of the weak areas customers name, then of whether last year's work touched them. Four things tend to hold customer experience back along the way: window dressing, slipping basics, practical limits and budget cuts.

Frequently asked questions about flat customer satisfaction scores

Why is our customer satisfaction score flat when we have done so much?

Read it in order. Check where you rank among your peers, then the areas where customers rate you lowest, then whether last year's work touched those areas. Four things tend to hold customer experience back: window dressing, basics that slipped, a fix that is not practical to make fast, and a budget cut to training or customer experience.

What counts as a flat score here?

A study result that has not changed across your recent results. It says nothing yet about why, which is what the reading order is for.

Do the same drivers apply in every industry?

No. In a utility the two biggest drivers are whether the service works and price, but what matters differs across water, gas, electric and internet companies, and across industries. Read your study in your own industry's terms.

Is NPS enough to tell us why?

No. NPS is a direction: it shows which way customers lean. It does not get down to what is going well or what you need to fix.

What if the work is good and customers do not credit it?

An area can be rated low because customers have not been told about work that is good. Tell them, and also check inside, because where customers do not recognize you as doing well there is probably something to change.

Mike Forsyth

About the author

Mike Forsyth

Mike Forsyth founded MJKD and Associates in 2008 and leads every engagement with John Farstvedt. He has walked into utilities, insurers, mortgage servicers, airlines, and automotive retail networks for eighteen years to find the handful of things that actually move the customer's experience.

Free CX Review

One hour with two senior partners.

Book My Free CX Review

Prefer to call or email? 210-876-4086 · info@mjkda.com